Site Navigation

Name: Stilwell Insurance Agency, Inc.
Telephone: (815) 844-5057

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
FAQ

Stilwell Insurance Agency, Inc.

About Us

Stilwell Insurance Agency, Inc., based in Pontiac, IL, has been a trusted insurance provider since 1979, serving Livingston County with a strong commitment to customer satisfaction. We offer comprehensive insurance services, including life, business, health, auto, and home coverage. Our dedicated team focuses on personalized service, ensuring each client finds the right insurance solutions to meet their unique needs. Contact us today for a consultation and secure your peace of mind with Stilwell Insurance Agency, Inc.

Areas Served

Our Professional Associations

Pontiac Area Chamber of Commerce

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Life
Business
Health
Auto
Home
Motorcycle
RV
Boat

Our Services include:

Life Insurance: Life is full of beautiful moments—and unexpected ones too. Our life insurance plans are designed to give you peace of mind, knowing your loved ones will be protected no matter what the future holds. Whether you're starting a family, planning for retirement, or simply want to leave a legacy, we’ll help you choose coverage that fits your goals and budget.
Business Insurance: Your business is more than just a job—it’s your passion, your livelihood, and your legacy. We offer customized business insurance solutions to protect everything you’ve built, from property and liability coverage to workers’ compensation and professional risk. Whether you're a startup or a seasoned enterprise, we’re here to help you grow with confidence.
Health Insurance: Your health is your foundation. We make it easy to find coverage that fits your lifestyle, your family, and your budget. From individual plans to family coverage and supplemental options, we’ll walk you through your choices and help you understand what’s best for your needs. Because when it comes to your well-being, you deserve clarity and care.
Auto Insurance: From daily commutes to weekend getaways, your vehicle is part of your life’s rhythm. Our auto insurance policies are built to protect you on the road—whether you're driving across town or across the country. We offer competitive rates, flexible coverage options, and personalized service to keep you moving forward with confidence.
Home Insurance: Your home is where your story begins. Whether you own or rent, we provide coverage that protects your space, your belongings, and your peace of mind. From fire and storm damage to theft and liability, we’ll help you safeguard what matters most—so you can focus on making memories, not worrying about “what ifs.”
Motorcycle Insurance: There’s nothing like the freedom of the open road. Our motorcycle insurance is designed for riders who want protection without sacrificing adventure. We cover everything from cruisers to sport bikes, with options for liability, collision, and gear protection. Ride with confidence—knowing we’ve got your back.
RV Insurance: Whether you're exploring the country or camping under the stars, your RV is your home away from home. We offer specialized coverage for motorhomes, travel trailers, and campers, including protection for your vehicle, personal belongings, and roadside assistance. Wherever your journey takes you, we’ll help you travel with peace of mind.
Boat Insurance: Life is better on the water—and we’re here to keep it that way. Our boat insurance covers everything from fishing boats to pontoons, with protection for your vessel, equipment, and liability. Whether you're cruising the lake or docking at the marina, we’ll help you stay safe and enjoy every wave.

Our Brands include:

Progressive
Madison Mutual
National General
Foremost
IMT
Mendota Mutual
First Chicago

Testimonials

On 9/27/2024 MOCHI FRIED ICECREAM had this to say:
Susan was the best bringing the information to needed it’s great working with her

On 3/19/2023 Kyle Condon had this to say:
Very friendly staff that found the best rates for basic liability coverage and it only took them a day to do it.

On 3/19/2022 Donald Moyer had this to say:
Great place miss Bill

On 3/19/2021 Deb Fultz had this to say:
Excellent customer service rep

On 3/19/2021 Jackie Barlow had this to say:
Stillwell insurance is very helpful. Every time I call they answer all my questions. The people that wotk there are pleasant and professional.

Contact Us

Stilwell Insurance Agency, Inc.
101 N Mill St Pontiac, IL 61764
Phone: (815) 844-5057
Fax: (815) 844-3868
Email: stilwell@mchsi.com

Downtown Pontiac - First building over the bridge on the left coming north.

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

Debit & Credit Cards, Cash, Checks

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

FAQ

What types of insurance does Stilwell Insurance Agency offer?

Stilwell Insurance Agency provides a wide range of coverage options including auto, home, life, health, and business insurance. Their team works closely with clients to tailor policies that meet individual and commercial needs.

How can I get a quote for insurance coverage?

You can request a personalized quote by filling out our form on our contact page or by phone. We will guide you through the process and help identify the best coverage options for your situation.

For Accurate Quotes please provide the following information:
Auto Insurance
•Driver information: Name, date of birth, license number, driving history
•Vehicle details: Year, make, model, VIN, mileage, usage (commute, pleasure, business)
•Coverage preferences: Liability limits, comprehensive/collision, deductibles
•Current insurance: Carrier name, coverage details, expiration date

Homeowners Insurance
•Property address
•Home details: Year built, square footage, construction type, roof age, security systems
•Occupancy: Owner-occupied, rental, seasonal
•Coverage needs: Dwelling, personal property, liability, flood or earthquake (if applicable)
•Current insurance: Carrier and coverage details

Life Insurance
•Full name, date of birth, gender
•Height, weight, tobacco use
•Medical history (conditions, medications)
•Occupation and lifestyle risks
•Desired coverage amount and term
•Beneficiary details

Business Insurance
•Business name, address, and type
•Years in operation
•Annual revenue
•Number of employees
•Description of operations
•Assets to insure (equipment, inventory, property)
•Coverage needs (liability, property, workers’ comp, etc.)

Health Insurance
•Full name, date of birth, gender
•Household size and income (for subsidies)
•Existing conditions or medications
•Preferred doctors/hospitals
•Coverage preferences (deductibles, copays, network type)

Motorcycle Insurance
•Rider info: name, DOB, license number, riding history
•Motorcycle details: year, make, model, VIN
•Usage: daily, seasonal, recreational
•Safety features and modifications
•Desired coverage: liability, collision, comprehensive

RV Insurance
•Owner info: name, DOB, license number
•RV details: year, make, model, VIN, type (motorhome, travel trailer)
•Usage: full-time, seasonal, vacation
•Storage location
•Coverage needs: liability, collision, comprehensive, personal belongings

Boat Insurance
•Owner info: name, DOB, boating experience
•Boat details: year, make, model, length, engine type
•Usage: freshwater, saltwater, personal, commercial
•Storage location
•Coverage needs: hull, liability, trailer, accessories

What’s the difference between term and whole life insurance?

Term life covers you for a set period (like 10 or 20 years), while whole life provides lifelong coverage and builds cash value. We’ll help you choose what’s best for your goals.

What makes Stilwell Insurance Agency different from other providers?

We emphasize personalized service, ensuring each client receives attention and solutions tailored to your unique needs. Our long-standing presence in the community reflects a commitment to trust and customer satisfaction.